Sample Proposal Analysis

Textbooks: (2)
Strength-addresses solution with specific statistics, gives reasonable population
Weakness-doesn't address counter-arguments, more justification for the change needed

Meal Plan: (1)
Strength-provides logical compromise as solution, problem is relevant to the population, good use of counter-argument
Weakness-anti-sexist arguments are inherently sexist, continues to address problem in justification (weakens argument)

Nuclear Power: (3)
Strength-lots of background to help audience understand difficult topic, no clear solution
Weakness-boring subject, confusing sources